From the late 1940s to the mid-1970s, men’s adventure magazines published stories by many writers who were either famous at the time or later became famous, such as Elmore Leonard, Mario Puzo, Mickey Spillane, Harlan Ellison and Jim Thompson.
The writers mentioned above are best known today for their novels. Other authors who wrote for men’s adventure magazines are now known more for their non-fiction.
One of the best and most prolific writers in the latter category is Robert F. Dorr.
Between 1958 and 1975, Dorr wrote hundreds of stories for a long list of men’s adventure magazines, including Action for Men, Bluebook, Escape to Adventure, For Men Only, Man to Man, Male, Man’s Magazine and Real — as well as for men’s adventure/bachelor magazine hybrids like Sir! and Stag.
After the 1970s, Robert F. Dorr went on to become one of our country’s most esteemed military historians.
He has authored 70 books and literally thousands of articles about World War II, the Korean War, the Vietnam War, military aviation, international affairs and related topics.
Dorr’s most recent book is Hell Hawks!: The Untold Story of the American Fliers Who Savaged Hitler's Wehrmacht
— which he co-wrote with former U.S. astronaut Thomas D. Jones. It tells the story of American pilots in 365th Fighter Group, who played a crucial role on the European front during World War II.
One reviewer has aptly described it as “‘Band of Brothers’ with planes.” (Hell Hawks! is currently available in bookstores, online, or by emailing Bob at robert.f.dorr@cox.net.)
I had the pleasure of talking with Bob recently, after he stumbled on this blog and sent me an email.
In the weeks ahead, I plan to post a number of his stories from the vintage magazines I have in my collection.
I will also pass along some of the anecdotes he has told me.
I’ll start with his gripping Korean War story “Charge of the Mad Machine Gunner,” from the January 1967 issue of Man’s Magazine.
It tells the saga of an American soldier who became a hero during a bloody fight with North Koreans near Seoul in 1950.
It’s the featured story on the cover, which has a superb cover painting by Mel Crair.
Bob Dorr told me that Crair’s painting was created for the story, instead of the other way around, as often happened in the men’s adventure magazines.
Crair was a versatile artist who provided covers and interior art for many of the men’s adventure magazine titles, as well as for other magazine genres and paperback books.
According to the book Men’s Adventure Magazines by Rich Oberg, Adam Parfrey and George Hagenauer, Mel Crair was first “discovered” by Pocket Books art director Sol Immerman.
And, during the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s, Crair painted covers for many paperback books.
Below are three examples from the early ‘60s that were edited by Phil Hirsch — who was the editor of Man’s Magazine when it published Dorr’s “Charge of the Mad Machine Gunner” in 1967.
“Charge of the Mad Machine Gunner” is a good example of the type of war stories Dorr wrote for the men’s adventure magazines. It’s exciting to read and full of factually accurate details. (You can read the entire story in PDF format by clicking on this link.)
Because the story is so realistic and includes so many details, and because Bob is now a critically acclaimed historian, I had assumed it was true. Bob told me it was fact-based, but fictional — like many “true stories” in men’s adventure magazines.
“For my first five to ten years writing for men’s adventure magazines,” Bob recalled, “I submitted my stories and the editors didn’t ask if they were true. Eventually, there was one occasion when an article was concocted over the telephone, to fit a piece of art. That happened in a conversation I had with Mel Shestack, editor of Men magazine at Magazine Management, who seemed blithely unaware I had been making up most of my stories all along.”
I probably should have known that Bob’s “Charge of the Mad Machine Gunner” was fiction, even though it includes a photo purportedly showing the soldier who is the central character. The use of photos in faux “true stories” was a common practice in the men’s adventure magazines.
But Bob’s writing is so realistic that I wouldn’t have been surprised if the Korean War incident it describes was a famous piece of real history – like his book Hell Hawks! and the many other books he has written
in recent years.
By the way, I highly recommend that you get a copy of Hell Hawks! if you haven’t read it yet. You can also “talk” about it with Bob his fans online by joining the Hell Hawks! Facebook Group — which already has hundreds of members.